We went to the first screening of a film Hope Gap by William Nicholson which is due to be released at some point in the future: a horribly realistic and all too believable depiction of the break-up of a marriage after 29 years between a schoolmaster (Bill Nighy) and his clever and interesting wife (Annette Benning) who cannot stop needling him until finally he goes away; and the horrible consequences of their divorce on her and their son who is compelled, but hopelessly, to mediate. It says at the end that it bears not the faintest resemblance to anyone either living or dead, but I am not convinced that this is true, which makes what is shown worse.
Author Archives: Charles Saumarez Smith
Stirling Prize 2019
Having just been sent a copy of the RIBA Journal which contains all the RIBA regional architectural awards, I was speculating over lunch with one of the architects who may be included which of the projects might make it onto the Stirling Prize shortlist.
Here are my own suggestions:-
Kengo Kuma’s V&A Dundee
I haven’t yet seen it, but reports are generally good, particularly of its overall massing and effect on the economics of Dundee. The grandest and most striking of this year’s projects, but I’m not convinced this means it should win.
Peter Zumthor’s Secular Retreat
Deserves short-listing for the quality of its ambition, use of materials and understated modernism.
Witherford Watson Mann’s Nevill Holt Opera House
Judges will no doubt resist such an obviously elitist project, attached to a country house and privately funded by its owner, but it is brilliantly well crafted and amazing in the way that it is so discreetly inserted into the adjoining stable block.
Adam Richards’s Nithurst Farm
I would be in favour of including some small-scale projects so the award is not always dominated by big capital schemes. This looks interesting – a piece of Piranesian vernacular.
Peter Barber’s Ordnance Road, Enfield
Barber is the architect of the moment and social housing the biggest challenge, so they should include some social housing projects.
6a architects’ Blue Mountain School
A lovely, small, intelligent project, a bit wacky, but none the worse for this; actually, it’s what makes it interesting.
The Shakespeare Gallery
It is the first time for a long time (eleven years at least) that I have been to the Royal Academy’s annual dinner as a guest rather than (part-) host.
Greg Doran, the Artistic Director of the Royal Shakespeare Company, gave a beautifully delivered and unusually historical speech on the nature of the relationship between the foundation of the Royal Academy in 1768 and its Schools in January the following year, and the eighteenth-century cult of Shakespeare, inaugurated in 1769 by David Garrick, who knew Reynolds through their fellow membership of The Club (Garrick would have been one of the founder members, but was regarded as too self important). Both Academy and the Shakespeare cult shared a belief in the importance of history and the grand tradition, as well as what Doran described as the liberty of modern interpretation (what he called ‘the nowness of now’).
In November 1786, Alderman Boydell established the Shakespeare Gallery which celebrated Shakespeare’s work by commissioning pictures based on his plays and Doran looks out on one of its surviving works, the sculpture of Shakespeare seated between the Dramatic Muse and the Genius of Painting by Thomas Banks. It moved to Stratford in 1871.
West Devon
We spent the weekend in west Devon – unspoilt farmland west of Dartmoor, full of cross-country lanes, small villages and distant views:-






Endsleigh (2)
We went back to Endsleigh: a garden of exceptional beauty, with the terrace in front of the house overlooking a steep descent into the valley of the Tamar and the banks of trees in the woods beyond. We learned that a key figure in the development of the proto-Victorian aesthetic – much use of rhodedendra and steep planting – may have been the second wife of the sixth Duke of Bedford, who was the daughter of the Duke of Gordon and had been brought up in the Highlands; and Repton of course, who was first consulted in 1809, displaced as architect by Wyatville the following year, and then returned in August 1814 to draw up the detailed plans contained in his Red Book.
The terrace:-

The gravel walk:-

The planting above the gravel walk:-

And the Shell House at the end of the terrace:-

Launceston (2)
I called in on Launceston’s parish church with its strange carved granite exterior. Mary Magdalene in the niche over the porch is not pre-Reformation, but put there in 1911:-


The carving make it look as if it is built out of soapstone:-



Indoors, a fine pulpit:-


Launceston (1)
We went into Launceston, an old market town, with castle, museum (closed) and war memorial, guarding the entrance to Cornwall on a hill called Dunsheved, with plenty of signs of Victorian prosperity, but now with all the hallmarks of urban decay – too much out-of-town shopping and charity shops.
Still, it has a fine medieval entrance gateway:-

And a good town centre:-




Endsleigh
We had a cup of tea on the terrace of Wyatville’s cottage ornée at Endsleigh, overlooking the heavily wooded valley of the Tamar, planted out following the prescriptions of Humphrey Repton’s Red Book, which dates from 1814 and still survives: a deeply romantic view to match the picturesque fantasy of the house itself, where the sixth Duke of Bedford could retreat while looking after his nearby estates:-

Castle Drogo
We called in at Castle Drogo, Lutyens’s last, great, romantic castle on a hill north of Dartmoor, where Julius Drewe, who made a fortune out of the Home and Colonial Stores, established himself in castellated splendour; but the house is being radically restored because Lutyens was hopeless at plumbing, so there was not much to see except the long corridors of his extended house plan:-


St. Paul’s Cathedral (6)
Readers of my blog will know that I never miss an opportunity to study, celebrate and enjoy the amazing stone carving with which the essential Baroque structure of St. Paul’s, stolid and agreed at the beginning of the design, was enriched and embellished by craftsmen working in the School of Wren, including work by Grinling Gibbons and Caius Gabriel Cibber in the north and south Tympana and, following Cibber’s death in 1700, much of it by Francis Bird, who had worked under both before travelling to Italy.
The great columns and capitals of the West Front were based on drawings by Wren from the 1690s:-


But who carved the smaller decorative putti and the rich, surrounding carving, so full of swagger and so carefully individualised ?





You must be logged in to post a comment.